Discover the Best Year for a Used Subaru Crosstrek

The best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek is the 2017 model, which delivers exceptional reliability and value after the first-generation’s kinks were resolved. For buyers seeking the latest safety and tech, the post-2018 redesign models are excellent but come with a premium.

Let’s be honest. Shopping for a used car can feel like a maze. You want something reliable, safe, and ready for adventure without blowing your budget. If you’re here, you’ve likely zeroed in on the Subaru Crosstrek. Smart move. It’s that perfect blend of compact size, go-anywhere confidence, and practical sensibility.

I remember helping a friend find her first “real” car after college. She needed something for snowy commutes and weekend hikes. The Crosstrek checked every box. But then came the big question: which year is the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek? With models spanning over a decade, the answer isn’t always straightforward. Some years are rock-solid, while others have known quirks.

That’s exactly why we’re here. Think of this as a friendly chat over coffee, where we break down the Crosstrek’s history, weigh the pros and cons, and help you find that sweet spot—the model year that gives you the most value and peace of mind for your hard-earned money. No sales pitch, just straight talk from one car enthusiast to another.

Key Takeaways

• 2014-2015 models are top picks: They balance cost and reliability post-launch.
• 2018 marks a major upgrade: New design with enhanced safety and tech.
• Seek 2019+ for EyeSight: Advanced safety features become standard.
• Steer clear of 2013: First-year models had more issues.
• Certified pre-owned adds value: Offers warranty and thorough inspection.
• Inspect maintenance records: Crucial for assessing long-term reliability.
• Compare trim packages: Features vary significantly by year and trim.

The Allure of the Used Subaru Crosstrek

Before we dive into specific years, let’s talk about why this little SUV is so popular. The Crosstrek isn’t just a car; it’s a lifestyle choice for many. It appeals to outdoor lovers, small families, and city dwellers alike.

Why Buyers Keep Coming Back

First, standard all-wheel drive. In a world where many competitors charge extra for AWD, Subaru includes it on every Crosstrek. This isn’t just for snow. It means better traction on rainy roads and muddy trails.

Second, legendary safety. Subaru’s EyeSight driver-assist technology, available on most newer models, is a game-changer. It can help prevent accidents.

Third, it’s incredibly practical. The cargo space is generous for its class. The fuel economy is respectable. It’s a vehicle that does a little bit of everything well.

Buying used lets you get into this capable package at a lower cost. You avoid the steepest depreciation hit. That makes finding the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek a very smart financial move.

Decoding the Best Year: What to Look For

“Best” means different things to different people. Your perfect year might depend on your budget, desired features, or tolerance for potential repairs. Let’s outline the key factors.

Your Personal Checklist

Budget: Older models (2013-2015) are more affordable. Newer ones (2018+) offer modern features but cost more.

Reliability and Recalls: Some years have fewer common issues. We’ll get into that.

Technology and Safety: Do you want Apple CarPlay? What about adaptive cruise control? Major updates came in 2018 and 2021.

Engine Performance: The standard 2.0-liter engine is adequate for most. A more powerful 2.5-liter option arrived in 2021. This is a big deal for highway merging.

Remember, the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek for you balances these factors. Let’s look at the history.

Subaru Crosstrek Model Year Breakdown (2013-2024)

Here’s a detailed, year-by-year guide. We’ll highlight the highs and lows of each generation to give you a clear picture.

The First Generation (2013-2017)

The Crosstrek debuted for the 2013 model year. It was essentially a raised Subaru Impreza hatchback. This generation built the car’s reputation.

2013-2015 Models: These are the budget-friendly pioneers. They established the formula. Watch for higher mileage examples. Some early models had minor issues with infotainment systems or wheel bearings. Overall, they are simple and robust.

2016-2017 Models: These years got a subtle facelift and smoother CVT transmission. Standard rearview camera in 2016 was a nice upgrade. Reliability is generally strong. These are often considered the sweet spot of the first gen.

The Second Generation (2018-2023)

A complete redesign. This is where the Crosstrek grew up. It got a new platform, more interior space, and better ride quality.

2018-2020 Models: The 2018 refresh was huge. The interior felt much more modern. EyeSight became more widely available. The 2019 model saw the addition of Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. These years are very popular on the used market.

2021-2023 Models: A significant update. The big news was the optional 2.5-liter engine in the Sport and Limited trims. More power solved the biggest complaint about the Crosstrek. Safety features were also enhanced.

The Current Generation (2024+)

A new redesign with hybrid options. As used models, these are rare and pricey. We’ll focus on earlier, more accessible years.

Crosstrek Model Year Snapshot

Model Years	Key Highlights	Things to Note
2013-2015	Lowest entry price, proven mechanicals, simple design.	Check for infotainment glitches, higher wear items.
2016-2017	Refined CVT, standard backup camera, great reliability.	A prime target for the best value in the first gen.
2018-2020	New platform, more space, better tech, EyeSight common.	High demand. Ensure pre-purchase inspection is done.
2021-2023	Available 2.5L engine, updated styling, top safety scores.	Premium for the extra power. Later years hold value well.

This table helps visualize the evolution. It shows why pinpointing the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek requires looking at your needs.

Top Picks for the Best Used Crosstrek Year

Based on reliability, features, and overall value, here are our top recommendations.

Best Overall Value: 2017 or 2019

This is a tie between two standout years.

The 2017 model represents the first generation at its most polished. You get the reliability kinks worked out, the better CVT, and that standard backup camera. It’s often priced very attractively.

The 2019 model is a star of the second generation. It has the modern platform, Apple CarPlay/Android Auto, and widespread availability of EyeSight. It strikes a fantastic balance between newness and affordability.

For most people, either of these could be the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek. The 2017 is for the budget-conscious classic fan. The 2019 is for the tech-savvy adventurer.

Best for Performance: 2021 or Newer

If you dread the idea of a slow car, your search should start here. The 2.5-liter engine option in 2021+ models transforms the driving experience. It has plenty of passing power. The Sport and Limited trims from these years are fantastic.

Yes, you’ll pay more. But for many, the extra confidence on highways is worth it. This makes the 2021 a top contender for the best year if power is your priority.

Best Budget Pick: 2014 or 2015

Your dollars will stretch furthest here. These early models are everywhere. They have the core Crosstrek DNA—AWD, safety, utility—at a very low cost. Just be prepared for fewer bells and whistles. Plan for a thorough inspection and possibly some minor repairs.

For a first car or a dedicated winter beater, these years are hard to beat.

Smart Shopping Tips for Your Used Crosstrek

Knowing the best year is half the battle. Here’s how to execute a smart purchase.

Get the Vehicle History Report

Always, always get a CARFAX or AutoCheck report. Look for a clean title, regular maintenance records, and no major accidents. One owner cars are usually a good sign.

Insist on a Pre-Purchase Inspection

This is non-negotiable. Spend $100-$200 for a trusted mechanic to look the car over. They can spot issues you might miss. This is crucial for any used car, especially when deciding on the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek.

Test Drive the Right Way

Don’t just drive around the block. Take it on the highway. Listen for unusual CVT whine or rattles. Test all the electronics. Check the air conditioning and heat. Feel how the brakes respond.

Negotiate with Knowledge

Use what you’ve learned. If you’re looking at a 2016 model, you know it’s a reliable year, but you can point out any wear items like tires or brake pads to negotiate a fair price.

Final Verdict: Our Pick for the Best Year

After all this, if we have to choose one model year that offers the best blend of everything, it would be the 2019 Subaru Crosstrek.

Here’s why. It sits in the sweet spot of the second generation. The major redesign bugs were worked out after the 2018 launch. It comes standard with the smartphone integration everyone wants. EyeSight is very common, adding a huge safety net. The prices, while higher than the first gen, are becoming very reasonable on the used market.

It’s not the cheapest, nor the most powerful (unless you find a rare 2019 with the newer engine, but that was 2021). But for overall reliability, modern features, safety, and retained value, the 2019 is incredibly hard to top. For a huge number of buyers, this will indeed be the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek.

Your journey to finding the perfect used Crosstrek is unique. Maybe the 2017’s value calls to you. Or perhaps the 2021’s power is a must-have. Armed with this knowledge, you can shop with confidence. You’re not just buying a car. You’re investing in countless adventures ahead. Take your time, do your homework, and you’ll find a Crosstrek that feels like it was made just for you. Happy trails!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek?

The 2018 model year is widely regarded as the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek due to its comprehensive redesign, which brought enhanced safety features, better fuel efficiency, and a more comfortable interior. It offers an ideal mix of modern updates and value, making it a top choice for used car shoppers.

Are there any model years of the Crosstrek I should avoid?

Some earlier years, particularly the 2013-2015 models, had common issues like oil consumption and infotainment system problems. While not inherently bad, it’s wise to prioritize later models or thoroughly inspect these older years for maintenance records before purchasing.

Which year offers the best value for a used Subaru Crosstrek?

The 2019 and 2020 model years are often seen as offering the best value for a used Subaru Crosstrek, as they retain the 2018 redesign improvements with added refinements and often include standard safety tech like EyeSight. They typically come with reasonable mileage and prices, providing a cost-effective way to get a reliable, feature-packed vehicle.

How does the 2021 Crosstrek compare to older models?

The 2021 Crosstrek stands out with an available more powerful 2.5-liter engine in higher trims, addressing prior performance concerns. However, it commands a higher price, so if you seek affordability, the 2018-2020 models remain excellent alternatives with proven reliability and similar core features.

Is the 2017 Subaru Crosstrek a good used buy?

Yes, the 2017 Crosstrek is a dependable used buy, especially if you prefer the pre-redesign style and want to save money. It lacks some newer amenities but is known for its ruggedness and lower cost of entry compared to subsequent model years.

What makes the 2018 model the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek?

The 2018 Crosstrek’s new global platform significantly improved ride comfort, handling, and safety ratings, while introducing modern tech like smartphone integration. These upgrades, combined with its strong reliability and accessible pricing on the used market, solidify its reputation as the best year for a used Subaru Crosstrek.