Choosing the right tires for your horse trailer is a serious decision. Your precious cargo relies on them for a smooth, safe journey. The best trailer tires for a horse trailer are built to handle heavy loads, resist wear, and provide stability on long hauls. This guide reviews ten top-rated options, from complete wheel assemblies to heavy-duty radials, to help you find the perfect fit for your rig and your peace of mind.
In This Article
- 1 Quick Product Comparison
- 2 Our Top 10 Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
- 2.1 1. Libra Trailer Parts ST205/75R15 Trailer Tires 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
- 2.2 2. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tire on Aluminum Rim 4.80-12 Load Range C with 5-Lug Black Wheel
- 2.3 3. 4.80-8 Trailer Tires with 8-Inch Rims 5 Lug on 4.5-Inch Load Range C 6-Ply Rating
- 2.4 4. Camco Trailer Aid Plus 5.5-Inch Lift Ramp for Changing RV and Trailer Tires Without Unloading
- 2.5 5. Forerunner QH505 Trailer Tire ST7.5-16 Load Range E 10-Ply with Black Sidewall
- 2.6 6. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tire 480
- 2.7 7. FREE COUNTRY Trailer Tire ST225/75R15 Radial 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
- 2.8 8. FREE COUNTRY Trailer Tire ST205/75R15 Radial 8-Ply Load Range D with Scuff Guard
- 2.9 9. ST205/75D15 Trailer Tires with 15-Inch Rims 5 Lug on 4.5-Inch Load Range C 6-Ply Rating
- 2.10 10. Carlisle Sport Trail 4.80
- 3 Complete Buying Guide for Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer
- 4 Frequently Asked Questions
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 10 Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Libra Trailer Parts ST205/75R15 Trailer Tires 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
For hauling heavy loads with confidence, the Libra ST205/75R15 tires are a top-tier choice. Their robust 10-ply Load Range E construction offers a massive 2,400-pound capacity per tire, making them ideal for larger multi-horse trailers.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Heavy-Duty 10-Ply Rating for maximum load capacity and durability.
✓ Full Nylon Cap Ply across the entire tread for superior strength and heat resistance.
✓ Integrated Scuff Guard ring protects tire sidewalls from curb damage.
✓ Radial design provides a smoother ride and better handling at highway speeds.
Why We Recommend It
We recommend this tire because it doesn’t cut corners on safety. The full nylon overlay is a premium feature you don’t always find, significantly reducing the risk of blowouts. For serious haulers, this build quality is worth the investment.
Best For
Owners of larger two-horse or stock trailers who need the highest load capacity and durability for frequent, long-distance travel.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Extremely high load rating perfect for heavy trailers.
- Premium full nylon cap ply construction for added safety.
- Scuff guard protects your investment from common roadside hazards.
- Radial design offers a comfortable and stable towing experience.
Cons:
- Higher price point than standard load range D tires.
- The stiff sidewalls can make mounting a challenge without professional tools.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “These tires have been fantastic on my 20-foot stock trailer. They feel solid and don’t sway even with a heavy load. The scuff guard already saved me once when I got too close to a concrete divider.”
Customer Review: “After a bad blowout with a cheap tire, I upgraded to these. The difference in how the trailer tracks is night and day. They’re worth every penny for the peace of mind.”
2. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tire on Aluminum Rim 4.80-12 Load Range C with 5-Lug Black Wheel
This eCustomrim package solves two problems at once: new tires and new wheels. It’s a complete, ready-to-bolt-on assembly that saves you a trip to the tire shop, perfect for upgrading small to mid-size utility or horse trailers.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Complete assembly includes tire, aluminum rim, valve stem, and lug nuts.
✓ Load Range C rating with a 990-pound max load per tire.
✓ DOT approved with a full two-year warranty and free roadside assistance.
✓ 5-lug on 4.5-inch bolt pattern is common for many smaller trailers.
Why We Recommend It
We love the convenience. If your old wheels are rusty or you’re replacing a damaged rim, this bundle is a game-changer. The aluminum wheels are corrosion-resistant and lighter than steel, and having them pre-mounted is a huge time-saver.
Best For
Trailer owners looking for a hassle-free, complete wheel and tire replacement for smaller trailers, or anyone wanting to upgrade to more durable aluminum rims.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Ultra-convenient pre-mounted assembly, ready to install.
- Aluminum rims resist rust and look cleaner than steel.
- Includes a solid warranty and roadside assistance for peace of mind.
- Saves money on mounting and balancing fees.
Cons:
- Specific to one bolt pattern (5 on 4.5″), so verify your trailer’s fit first.
- Load range C may not be sufficient for the heaviest horse trailers.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Bought these for my horse trailer’s front axle. Bolted them on in 20 minutes and was back on the road. The aluminum wheels are a nice upgrade from the old rusty ones.”
Customer Review: “The convenience can’t be beat. The tires came perfectly balanced, and the warranty is a nice bonus. They’ve handled several long trips without issue.”
3. 4.80-8 Trailer Tires with 8-Inch Rims 5 Lug on 4.5-Inch Load Range C 6-Ply Rating
For small horse trailers, pony trailers, or utility trailers on a tight budget, this complete 2-pack is a lifesaver. It provides a cost-effective, ready-to-roll solution that gets your trailer back in service quickly.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Affordable set of two complete tire and wheel assemblies.
✓ 6-Ply Load Range C rating handles up to 745 lbs per tire.
✓ White steel wheels with a common 5 on 4.5″ bolt pattern.
✓ Pre-mounted and ready to install straight out of the box.
Why We Recommend It
We recommend this for its sheer value. If you have a small single-horse or cargo trailer, you don’t always need the most expensive tire. This set offers reliable performance at a price that makes routine replacement painless.
Best For
Owners of small, lightweight horse trailers or utility trailers who need a dependable, budget-friendly replacement option.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent value for a complete two-wheel set.
- Saves significant time and money on professional mounting.
- Adequate load rating for smaller trailer applications.
- Simple, bolt-on installation for most DIYers.
Cons:
- Steel wheels can be prone to rust over time.
- Not suitable for large or heavy horse trailers.
- Tread life may be shorter than premium radial tires.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Perfect for my little two-horse bumper pull. They got me back on the road after a flat for a very reasonable price. Installation was straightforward.”
Customer Review: “For the price, you can’t go wrong. They’ve held up well for a season of light use hauling hay and my pony. Exactly what I needed.”
4. Camco Trailer Aid Plus 5.5-Inch Lift Ramp for Changing RV and Trailer Tires Without Unloading
This isn’t a tire, but it’s essential gear for anyone who trailers horses. The Camco Trailer Aid Plus is a brilliant tool that lets you change a flat on a tandem-axle trailer without unloading your animals or wrestling with a jack on soft ground.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Creates a 5.5-inch lift by driving the good tire onto the ramp.
✓ Allows tire change without removing horses, tack, or cargo.
✓ Made from tough, lightweight, and waterproof polymer.
✓ Simple to use – just place it in front of the good tire and drive forward.
Why We Recommend It
We think every horse trailer should have one of these in the tack compartment. It turns a potential roadside nightmare—unloading a nervous horse on a busy highway—into a quick, 10-minute fix. It’s pure peace of mind.
Best For
Every horse owner who trailers, especially those who travel alone or on long trips where roadside assistance may be delayed.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Eliminates the need to unload animals during a tire change.
- Extremely simple and fast to use in an emergency.
- Lightweight and stores easily in a side compartment.
- Durable and rust-proof construction.
Cons:
- Only works on trailers with tandem (or more) axles.
- Requires enough space in front of or behind the good tire to place it.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “I have to use this today! This worked exactly, and I mean exactly as advertised… Made changing the flat I had very quick, around 5-7 minutes. No messing with a jack…”
Customer Review: “I wanted to check the wheel bearings and couldn’t find the proper way to jack up the side… This ramp was the perfect, safe solution to lift one tire off the ground.”
5. Forerunner QH505 Trailer Tire ST7.5-16 Load Range E 10-Ply with Black Sidewall
The Forerunner QH505 is a heavy-duty bias-ply tire built for larger trailers that demand a high load capacity. Its ST7.5-16 size and Load Range E rating make it a workhorse for big rigs.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ ST7.5-16 Size with a 10-Ply Load Range E construction.
✓ Bias-ply design offers stiff sidewalls for excellent load stability.
✓ All-season, highway-performance tread pattern.
✓ Designed for heavy-duty trailer applications.
Why We Recommend It
We recommend this tire for its sheer toughness in a specific size. If your gooseneck or large horse trailer calls for an ST7.5-16 tire, this is a reliable and well-regarded option that provides great value in that niche.
Best For
Owners of larger gooseneck horse trailers, livestock trailers, or equipment trailers that require the ST7.5-16 tire size.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Very high load capacity suitable for the largest trailers.
- Sturdy bias-ply construction resists sidewall flex under heavy loads.
- Good availability and value in this less-common size.
- Durable all-season compound.
Cons:
- Bias-ply tires typically provide a slightly firmer ride than radials.
- Ensure this exact size (ST7.5-16) matches your trailer’s requirements.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Worth the money as great tire for my trailer. Correct size and as I just got them feel the quality is very good.”
Customer Review: “The price was good. The shipping was unbelievably fast! FedEx delivered the tires right next to the trailer that they went on. I can’t be happier!”
6. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tire 480
This two-pack of 4.80-12 bias-ply trailer tires from eCustomrim is a solid, no-frills replacement option. With a deep tread design and Load Range B rating, they are built for lighter-duty utility and small trailers.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ 2-pack of bias-ply tires with a deep tread design for good traction.
✓ Load Range B with a 785-pound maximum load capacity.
✓ DOT approved and backed by a 2-year warranty.
✓ Simple, affordable tire replacement for standard wheels.
Why We Recommend It
We recommend these as a dependable, basic tire for non-critical applications. If you have a small utility trailer for hay or equipment and just need a reliable, affordable tire, this pair gets the job done.
Best For
Light utility trailers, small boat trailers, or as spares for trailers that use this common 4.80-12 tire size.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent price for a pair of tires.
- Deep tread provides good wear life and traction.
- Includes the manufacturer’s warranty.
- Simple replacement for existing rims.
Cons:
- Load Range B is the lightest rating, not for heavy loads.
- You’ll need to pay for mounting and balancing separately.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Good quality, durable, sized correctly, and good value. Installation was simple and they have functioned perfectly. I put them on a 5’x8’ trailer.”
Customer Review: “Great deal on a pair of trailer tires. Easy enough to install without a tire machine.”
7. FREE COUNTRY Trailer Tire ST225/75R15 Radial 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
The FREE COUNTRY ST225/75R15 is a wider, high-capacity sibling to our top pick. The larger footprint and 10-ply radial construction provide immense stability and load-bearing ability for the biggest bumper-pull trailers.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Wider ST225/75R15 size for increased stability and load capacity.
✓ Radial 10-Ply Load Range E construction.
✓ Full nylon cap ply and protective Scuff Guard ring.
✓ Rated for speeds up to 88 mph (N rating).
Why We Recommend It
We recommend this tire when you need maximum footprint and capacity. The wider stance helps stabilize taller trailers, and the radial design ensures a smooth ride. It’s a premium choice for heavy, wide-track trailers.
Best For
Large, wide horse trailers or enclosed stock trailers that benefit from the increased stability of a 225-width tire.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Wider tire provides better traction and lateral stability.
- All the premium features of the top pick (full nylon cap, scuff guard).
- Higher speed rating suitable for highway towing.
- Excellent for heavy, wide-bodied trailers.
Cons:
- May not fit all trailer fenders—check clearance first.
- Typically more expensive than the 205 width.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “So far working good on my 16 foot trailer look great mounted good time will tell I suppose.”
Customer Review: “Upgraded from Load Range D to these Es. The trailer feels much more planted on the highway, especially when passing semis. No issues so far.”
8. FREE COUNTRY Trailer Tire ST205/75R15 Radial 8-Ply Load Range D with Scuff Guard
This is the perfect middle-ground tire. It offers the premium radial construction and scuff guard of the higher-end models but with an 8-ply Load Range D rating, making it a cost-effective choice for standard-sized horse trailers.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Steel-belted radial 8-Ply Load Range D construction.
✓ Full nylon cap ply across the entire tread area.
✓ Featured Scuff Guard sidewall protection.
✓ Excellent balance of performance, durability, and value.
Why We Recommend It
We recommend this tire for most standard two-horse bumper-pull trailers. The Load Range D rating is often perfectly adequate, and you still get the critical safety features like the full nylon cap ply and scuff guard at a more accessible price.
Best For
The majority of horse trailer owners with standard-sized trailers who want premium safety features without the top-tier Load Range E price.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent value with high-end safety features.
- Lighter and may provide a slightly softer ride than 10-ply tires.
- More than sufficient capacity for many common horse trailer configurations.
- Radial construction for better fuel economy and tread life.
Cons:
- Lower load rating than Load Range E tires (check your trailer’s needs).
- May not be ideal for trailers consistently loaded to maximum capacity.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “These replaced the original tires on my trailer. The ride is noticeably smoother, and I love having the sidewall protection. Great tires for the money.”
Customer Review: “After researching, this seemed like the smart choice for my needs. They’ve been through a hot summer of shows without any problems. Seem very well made.”
9. ST205/75D15 Trailer Tires with 15-Inch Rims 5 Lug on 4.5-Inch Load Range C 6-Ply Rating
This is a complete wheel and tire package in the popular ST205/75D15 size. It’s a fantastic option if you need to replace both the tire and the rim on a trailer that uses a 15-inch wheel with a 5 on 4.5″ bolt pattern.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Complete set of two ST205/75D15 tires mounted on 15-inch white steel wheels.
✓ Load Range C, 6-Ply rating with a 1,820-pound max load.
✓ Common 5-lug on 4.5-inch bolt pattern.
✓ Ready for immediate bolt-on installation.
Why We Recommend It
We recommend this for its convenience in a very common size. If your trailer uses this configuration, buying the pre-mounted set is often cheaper and always easier than buying components separately and paying for mounting.
Best For
Trailer owners needing a direct replacement for a worn-out ST205/75D15 tire and wheel combo, especially on mid-size utility or horse trailers.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Perfect “like-for-like” replacement package for a common trailer setup.
- Eliminates the guesswork and hassle of separate purchases.
- Good load capacity for many mid-size trailers.
- Affordable solution for a full wheel replacement.
Cons:
- Load Range C may be below the original specification for some horse trailers (check your sidewall).
- Steel wheels are basic and functional but not flashy.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Perfect fix to make an old trailer like new. Old tire and rim made a decent spare tire.”
Customer Review: “The tires were exactly as described and fit my trailer perfectly. Bolted them on in minutes. Great purchase for the price.”
10. Carlisle Sport Trail 4.80
The Carlisle Sport Trail is a trusted name in trailer tires. This bias-ply tire is designed specifically for towable trailers and represents a reliable, brand-name option for small trailers and equipment.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ From Carlisle (now Carlstar), a reputable brand with a long history.
✓ Designed for utility, boat, horse, stock, and cargo trailers.
✓ Bias-ply construction proven for trailer use.
✓ A known quantity in the trailer tire market.
Why We Recommend It
We recommend this tire for those who prefer a well-known brand they can trust. While it’s a basic bias-ply tire, it comes from a company that specializes in this area, which can be reassuring when so many off-brand options exist.
Best For
Anyone looking for a dependable, brand-name bias-ply tire for their small to mid-size trailer and who values established manufacturer reputation.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Backed by a reputable and experienced manufacturer.
- Proven design for various trailer applications.
- Generally good availability and consistent quality.
- A safe, standard choice for replacement.
Cons:
- May not have the latest premium features like full nylon cap or scuff guard.
- As a bias-ply tire, it won’t offer the ride smoothness of a radial.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Why did you pick this product vs others?:looks like a quality tire. heavier built than the 1 I’m replacing. recommend this tire”
Customer Review: “Not for it’s intended purpose, but these tire are great for 8 inch wheel barrel tire upgrade… Totally worth it though, no more flats on the jobsite anymore.”
Complete Buying Guide for Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer
Essential Factors We Consider
Picking the right tire isn’t just about size. You must match the tire to your trailer’s weight. First, find your tire’s Load Range (like C, D, or E). This tells you how much weight it can carry. A higher letter is stronger. Next, look at the Ply Rating (like 6-ply, 10-ply). More plies mean a tougher tire. Always choose a tire whose total capacity (per tire x number of tires) exceeds your trailer’s Gross Vehicle Weight Rating (GVWR). Don’t forget the size code (like ST205/75R15) on your old tire’s sidewall – that’s your shopping list.
Budget Planning
Your budget should balance cost with critical needs. For a small, lightly-used trailer, a Load Range C tire or a complete budget wheel set may be fine. For a large horse trailer you use often, investing in a premium radial tire with a full nylon cap ply and scuff guard is a smart safety investment. Remember to factor in the cost of mounting and balancing if you buy tires alone. Sometimes, a pre-mounted set, while higher upfront, saves you money on service fees.
Final Thoughts
The safest tire is one that’s not overloaded and is properly maintained. No matter what you choose, check air pressure before every trip – underinflation is a tire’s worst enemy. Inspect for cracks, cuts, or unusual wear regularly. Consider carrying a Trailer Aid ramp and a proper spare. Your tires are the only thing between your trailer and the road. It’s worth getting the best ones you can for your specific rig.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How often should I replace my horse trailer tires?
A: Replace trailer tires every 5-7 years, even if the tread looks good. The rubber compounds break down with age and exposure to sun and weather, increasing the risk of a blowout. Check the DOT code on the sidewall to find the manufacture date.
Q: Can I use passenger car tires on my horse trailer?
A: No. You should only use tires marked “ST” (Special Trailer). Trailer tires are built with stiffer sidewalls to handle the unique stresses of towing and heavy loads without swaying. Passenger tires are not designed for this and can fail dangerously.
Q: What’s the difference between bias-ply and radial trailer tires?
A: Bias-ply tires have a crisscross ply construction. They are tough, often cost less, and have very stiff sidewalls. Radial tires have plies that run perpendicular to the direction of travel. They run cooler, offer a smoother ride, and usually have better tread life, making them a great choice for highway travel.
Q: What does the “Scuff Guard” feature do?
A: A Scuff Guard is a raised, protective rubber ring molded into the sidewall of the tire. It helps protect the sidewall from damage if you rub against a curb or other obstacle during tight turns, which can prevent sidewall failure.
Q: Is a higher Load Range always better?
A: Not necessarily. A higher Load Range (E vs. D) means a stiffer, heavier tire with a higher capacity. If your trailer is light, a Load Range E tire might give an overly harsh ride. Match the Load Range to your trailer’s actual loaded weight for the best combination of performance, comfort, and safety.
Selecting the best trailer tires for your horse trailer is one of the most important safety decisions you can make as a hauler. The right tires provide stability, prevent blowouts, and ensure a calm, secure ride for your equine partners. We hope this detailed roundup helps you make a confident choice. For maximum load capacity and premium safety features, our top pick, the Libra Trailer Parts ST205/75R15 Load Range E, is an outstanding investment. Ready to upgrade your trailer’s safety and performance? Check the latest prices and options for these top-rated tires today.
At CarLegit, we believe information should be clear, factual, and genuinely helpful. That’s why every guide, review, and update on our website is created with care, research, and a strong focus on user experience.