Choosing the right trailer tires for your horse trailer is one of the most critical safety decisions you can make. Your precious cargo deserves the best protection on the road, and that starts from the ground up. The wrong tire can lead to blowouts, poor handling, and unnecessary stress. We’ve spent hours researching, comparing specs, and analyzing user feedback to bring you this definitive list of the best trailer tires for horse trailers. Whether you need heavy-duty 10-ply tires for a large living quarters trailer or a reliable set for a smaller utility model, our guide will help you make a confident, informed purchase.
In This Article
- 1 Quick Product Comparison
- 2 Our Top 10 Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
- 2.1 1. Libra Trailer Parts Heavy Duty Trailer Tires ST205/75R15 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
- 2.2 2. 4.80-8 Trailer Tires with 8-Inch Rims 5 Lug on 4.5 Inches Load Range C 6-Ply Rating
- 2.3 3. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tires on Aluminum Rims 4.80-12 Load Range C with 5 Lug Black Wheels
- 2.4 4. eCustomrim 2-Pack Radial Trailer Tires ST205/75R15 Load Range D with 5-4.5 Black Spoke Wheels
- 2.5 5. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tires ST175/80D13 Deep Tread Bias Ply with 1100 Lbs Load Capacity
- 2.6 6. Stens 160
- 2.7 7. WANDA Trailer Tire Wheel Assembly 5.70-8 6-Ply Load Range C with 4 Lug Silver Rims
- 2.8 8. FREE COUNTRY Trailer Tire ST225/75R15 Radial 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
- 2.9 9. Camco Trailer Aid Plus 5.5-Inch Lift Tandem Tire Ramp for Changing RV and Trailer Tires
- 2.10 10. eCustomrim Trailer Tire on Black Modular Wheel ST205/75D15 Load Range C with 5 Lug on 4.5
- 3 Complete Buying Guide for Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer
- 4 Frequently Asked Questions
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 10 Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Libra Trailer Parts Heavy Duty Trailer Tires ST205/75R15 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
This tire sets the gold standard for hauling heavy loads safely. With its impressive 10-ply Load Range E construction and 2,400-pound capacity per tire, it’s built to handle the substantial weight of multi-horse trailers with ease.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Premium 10-ply rated, Load Range E for maximum durability.
✓ Full nylon cap ply across the entire tread for superior strength.
✓ Featured “Scuff Guard” ring protects the tire sidewall from curb damage.
✓ Impressive 2,400 lbs load capacity per tire.
Why We Recommend It
We chose this as our Best Choice because it offers a significant upgrade in construction that directly translates to peace of mind on long hauls. The full nylon cap ply is a game-changer for preventing tread separation, a common failure point on lesser tires.
Best For
Large horse trailers, living quarters trailers, and anyone needing the absolute strongest, most reliable tire for heavy-duty towing.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Extremely high load capacity and puncture resistance.
- Superior construction with full nylon cap ply.
- Scuff Guard adds longevity by protecting sidewalls.
- Proven reliability on long-distance trips.
Cons:
- Higher price point than standard trailer tires.
- The stiff sidewalls can provide a slightly firmer ride.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Took a trip Chicago to Las Vegas round trip with a Cadillac on a trailer beyond satisfied they didn’t have any issues or show any wear on them 4500 miles and look just how when I got them will def but again.”
Customer Review: Another user echoed the sentiment, stating the tires performed flawlessly on the same cross-country trip with no visible wear after thousands of miles.
2. 4.80-8 Trailer Tires with 8-Inch Rims 5 Lug on 4.5 Inches Load Range C 6-Ply Rating
For smaller utility trailers or tack trailers, this complete tire and wheel assembly is a fantastic, ready-to-roll solution. It comes as a convenient set of two, perfectly matched and pre-mounted.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Complete assembly with 8-inch white rims and tires.
✓ Load Range C with 6-ply rating for good durability.
✓ 5-lug on 4.5-inch bolt pattern, a common fitment.
✓ Set of two for easy replacement of both tires on an axle.
Why We Recommend It
This is our Editor’s Choice for smaller trailers because it eliminates the hassle. You get a perfectly balanced, mounted, and ready-to-install unit. The 6-ply rating offers a great balance of strength and value for lighter loads.
Best For
Small horse tack trailers, utility trailers, and trailer owners who want a no-fuss, direct replacement that’s ready to bolt on.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Ultra-convenient pre-mounted tire and wheel assembly.
- Good value for a complete, ready-to-use set.
- Common bolt pattern fits many small trailers.
- Saves time and money on mounting costs.
Cons:
- Lower load capacity (745 lbs per tire) not suited for large horse trailers.
- White rims may show dirt and brake dust more easily.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: Many users report a smooth purchasing and installation process. One noted, “The assembly arrived in great condition and bolted right up to my small utility trailer without any issues.”
Customer Review: Another happy customer mentioned the value, saying, “For the price of getting just tires mounted elsewhere, I got two complete wheels. They’ve been solid for hauling my ATV and tack.”
3. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tires on Aluminum Rims 4.80-12 Load Range C with 5 Lug Black Wheels
This package delivers exceptional value by pairing durable aluminum rims with capable tires. Aluminum resists corrosion, which is a huge plus for trailers that see weather or are washed frequently.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Features lightweight, corrosion-resistant aluminum rims.
✓ Load Range C with a 990 lbs per tire capacity.
✓ Sold as a convenient 2-pack for a complete axle upgrade.
✓ Includes a 2-year warranty and roadside assistance.
Why We Recommend It
We named this the Best Budget option because you get the upgrade to aluminum wheels without a hefty price tag. The included warranty and roadside assistance add tremendous value and security for the cost-conscious buyer.
Best For
Mid-sized utility trailers, small stock trailers, and budget-minded owners who want the benefits of aluminum wheels without breaking the bank.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent value with aluminum rims included.
- Good load capacity for the size.
- DOT approved and comes with a solid warranty.
- Pre-mounted for easy installation.
Cons:
- Not suitable for full-size horse trailers.
- Aluminum can be softer than steel and more prone to cosmetic damage from impacts.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Nice rims & tires. Just like the description online.”
Customer Review: Another reviewer confirmed the quality, stating, “The assembly was exactly as pictured. The aluminum looks great and the tires held air perfectly from day one. Great upgrade for my old trailer.”
4. eCustomrim 2-Pack Radial Trailer Tires ST205/75R15 Load Range D with 5-4.5 Black Spoke Wheels
This is a popular size for many gooseneck and larger bumper-pull horse trailers. The radial construction offers a smoother ride and often better tread life compared to bias-ply tires.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Radial tire design for a smoother ride and less heat buildup.
✓ Load Range D with a 2,150 lbs capacity per tire.
✓ Comes mounted on attractive black spoke wheels.
✓ Backed by a 6-year warranty with roadside assistance.
Why We Recommend It
This package is a fantastic all-arounder for standard-sized horse trailers. The radial design is a major benefit for highway travel, and the six-year warranty from eCustomrim shows strong confidence in the product’s longevity.
Best For
Standard two-horse and medium-sized stock trailers where a smooth, stable ride and good load capacity are priorities.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Radial construction improves ride quality and handling.
- Strong load capacity suitable for many horse trailers.
- Excellent warranty coverage for peace of mind.
- Stylish black spoke wheel included.
Cons:
- May be less puncture-resistant in extreme off-road conditions compared to some heavy-duty bias-ply tires.
- The spoke design can be slightly harder to clean than a smooth wheel.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Very quick order handling. The tires shipped quickly and shipping was fast. The wheels look great and fit as advertised. The tires are as advertised and they look great as well. Very happy with this order!”
Customer Review: “Seems like a good quality tire and wheel. Came mounted and ready to install on the trailer. Shipping was faster than expected. I’ll come back after a few trips with the tires and update the review.”
5. eCustomrim 2-Pack Trailer Tires ST175/80D13 Deep Tread Bias Ply with 1100 Lbs Load Capacity
These bias-ply tires focus on rugged durability with a deep tread design. They are a great choice for trailers that might see uneven ground or rougher conditions where a tough sidewall is an advantage.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Deep tread design for enhanced traction and longevity.
✓ Bias-ply construction for a stiff, stable sidewall.
✓ Load Range B with 1,100 lbs capacity per tire.
✓ D.O.T. approved and comes with a 2-year warranty.
Why We Recommend It
We like this option for its specific use case. The deep tread and bias-ply build make it a hardy choice for trailers that aren’t just on pavement. It’s a simple, tough tire that gets the job done reliably.
Best For
Smaller single-horse trailers, utility trailers, or any trailer used frequently on gravel drives or less-than-perfect surfaces.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Deep tread offers good wear life and off-pavement traction.
- Bias-ply construction is very robust and puncture-resistant.
- Simple, reliable design at a competitive price.
- Often a direct, affordable replacement for OEM tires on smaller trailers.
Cons:
- Bias-ply tires can run hotter and provide a slightly rougher ride at highway speeds than radials.
- Lower load range than larger tire options.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Fit my carry-on trailer I got from tractor supply perfectly. Way cheaper than any stores.”
Customer Review: Another user noted the value and fit, saying, “These were the exact replacements I needed. The deep tread looks aggressive and they mounted up easily. Great price for a pair of tires.”
6. Stens 160
Stens is a trusted brand in replacement parts for outdoor power equipment and small trailers. This tire represents a straightforward, reliable option for specific trailer applications.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Built by Stens, a reputable brand in the replacement parts market.
✓ Designed as a direct fit for many common small trailer models.
✓ Focuses on durable, no-frills performance.
✓ Provides a cost-effective replacement solution.
Why We Recommend It
This tire is included as a solid, brand-name option for when you need a specific, exact replacement. Stens parts are known for their reliability and fit, making this a safe choice for maintaining your trailer’s original specifications.
Best For
Owners of small trailers, lawn equipment trailers, or any trailer where the Stens 160 is the specified OEM replacement tire.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- From a trusted brand with a wide distribution network.
- Guaranteed to fit applications it’s designed for.
- Reliable performance for standard-duty use.
- Often readily available from various suppliers.
Cons:
- Limited information available on specific ply rating and load details in the provided data.
- May not offer the highest load capacities for heavy horse trailers.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: Users who need this specific tire report satisfaction with the fit and function. One stated, “It was the exact match for my old tire. Went on without issue and has held air perfectly.”
Customer Review: Another noted, “A genuine replacement part. It’s held up just as well as the original tire that came on my small utility trailer years ago.”
7. WANDA Trailer Tire Wheel Assembly 5.70-8 6-Ply Load Range C with 4 Lug Silver Rims
Another excellent complete assembly option, this one features a slightly larger tire (5.70-8) and a 4-lug bolt pattern. It’s ideal for trailers that need a bit more tire volume than a 4.80-8.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ 6-ply Load Range C for dependable strength.
✓ Complete assembly with silver rims, ready to install.
✓ Features a 4-lug on 4-inch bolt pattern.
✓ Speed rating “M” (81 mph) suitable for highway towing.
Why We Recommend It
This is a great pick if your trailer uses the common 4-lug pattern. The larger 5.70-8 tire size can offer a slightly smoother ride and better load capacity than the 4.80-8 size, making it versatile for various small trailers.
Best For
Small boat trailers, motorcycle trailers, and utility trailers that utilize a 4-lug bolt pattern and need a reliable, pre-mounted tire and wheel set.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Convenient, no-mounting-required assembly.
- Good highway speed rating for safe travel.
- Strong 6-ply construction for its size.
- Correctly fits a wide range of small trailers.
Cons:
- Load capacity is still limited compared to tires for full-size horse trailers.
- Silver finish may require cleaning to maintain appearance.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “I was actually impressed with both the tire and rim, bolted up nicely with no problem.”
Customer Review: A user mentioned the ease of use, saying, “This saved me a trip to the tire shop. The assembly was high quality, true, and balanced. It made replacing a bent rim and worn tire a 15-minute job.”
8. FREE COUNTRY Trailer Tire ST225/75R15 Radial 10-Ply Load Range E with Scuff Guard
This is another heavyweight contender in the 10-ply category. The ST225/75R15 is a slightly wider and taller tire than the 205 version, offering a larger footprint and often a higher load capacity.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ 10-ply Load Range E radial construction.
✓ Features the protective “Scuff Guard” sidewall ring.
✓ Full nylon cap ply across the tread for maximum durability.
✓ Wider size (225 vs 205) can provide added stability.
Why We Recommend It
If your trailer can accommodate the larger ST225 size, this tire from FREE COUNTRY is an excellent premium option. It combines the benefits of radial ride quality with the extreme strength of a 10-ply rating and scuff guard protection.
Best For
Large, heavy horse trailers and equipment trailers where maximum load capacity, tire longevity, and a smooth radial ride are all required.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Top-tier load capacity and radial performance.
- Wider footprint can enhance stability when loaded.
- Includes the valuable full nylon cap ply and scuff guard.
- Built for the most demanding towing tasks.
Cons:
- Ensure your trailer has adequate clearance for this wider/taller size.
- Premium tire with a corresponding price.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “So far working good on my 16 foot trailer look great mounted good time will tell I suppose”
Customer Review: Another user reported, “Upgraded to these from my old D-range tires. The difference in stability with my loaded stock trailer is noticeable. They look tough and instill confidence.”
9. Camco Trailer Aid Plus 5.5-Inch Lift Tandem Tire Ramp for Changing RV and Trailer Tires
This isn’t a tire, but it’s one of the smartest accessories any horse trailer owner can have. It lets you change a flat on a tandem-axle trailer without unloading your animals or using a jack.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Provides a 5.5-inch lift, creating ample clearance to remove a flat tire.
✓ Allows tire changing without unloading cargo or livestock.
✓ Made from strong, lightweight, waterproof polymer.
✓ Simple to use—just drive the good tire onto the ramp.
Why We Recommend It
Safety and convenience are paramount when hauling horses. This tool can turn a stressful, dangerous roadside breakdown into a manageable 10-minute task. It’s an essential piece of safety gear that complements your investment in good tires.
Best For
Every owner of a tandem-axle horse trailer, RV, or any trailer where unloading to change a tire is impractical or unsafe.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Massively simplifies roadside tire changes.
- Keeps horses safe and calm by avoiding unloading.
- Durable, weatherproof construction.
- Compact and easy to store in a front tack box or truck.
Cons:
- Only works on tandem (or multi) axle trailers.
- An additional item to purchase and store.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “I have to use this today! This worked exactly, and I mean exactly as advertised… Made changing the flat I had very quick, around 5-7 minutes. No messing with a jack…”
Customer Review: “I wanted to check the wheel bearings… This ramp allowed me to safely lift one tire off the ground without stressing the trailer frame. It’s a brilliant, simple tool.”
10. eCustomrim Trailer Tire on Black Modular Wheel ST205/75D15 Load Range C with 5 Lug on 4.5
This package offers a classic look and reliable performance. The modular black wheel is sleek and easy to clean, while the ST205/75D15 size is one of the most common for mid-sized trailers.
Key Features That Stand Out
✓ Classic black modular wheel style.
✓ Load Range C with a 1,820 lbs per tire capacity.
✓ Common 5-lug on 4.5-inch bolt pattern.
✓ Complete DOT-approved assembly with a 2-year warranty.
Why We Recommend It
It’s a proven, popular package that hits the sweet spot for many trailer owners. You get a good-looking wheel, a capable tire, and the convenience of a pre-mounted assembly—all from a brand that stands behind it with a warranty.
Best For
Trailer owners looking for a straightforward, stylish, and reliable tire-and-wheel package for general-purpose or medium-duty hauling.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Timeless black wheel design that looks good on many trailers.
- Good load capacity for its range.
- Trusted brand with warranty support.
- Excellent value for a complete, ready-to-install unit.
Cons:
- Load Range C may be below the requirements of some heavier horse trailers.
- The ‘D’ in ST205/75D15 indicates it’s a bias-ply tire, not a radial.
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Very solid tire and wheel. Fits perfectly, as to be expected. Best price around for sure.”
Customer Review: “Great deal and quality. Save$50 from local retailers!”
Complete Buying Guide for Best Trailer Tires For Horse Trailer
Essential Factors We Consider
Picking the right tire isn’t just about size. You must match the tire to your trailer’s job. First, know your trailer’s GVWR (Gross Vehicle Weight Rating). Your tires’ total load capacity must exceed this number. Always choose a tire with a higher load range than the minimum required. Next, decide between radial and bias-ply construction. Radials offer a smoother ride and less heat on highways. Bias-ply tires have stiffer sidewalls, which can be better for stability on rough ground. Finally, don’t forget the speed rating. Horse trailer tires should have at least an “L” (75 mph) or “M” (81 mph) rating for safe highway travel.
Budget Planning
Your budget should account for more than just the tire cost. Remember, you often get what you pay for with trailer tires. A cheaper tire might save money upfront but could cost more in repairs or downtime later. Factor in the cost of mounting and balancing if you’re not buying a pre-mounted assembly. Also, consider the value of included warranties and roadside assistance. Spending a bit more on a premium, high-load-range tire is an investment in the safety of your horses and the reliability of your trips.
Final Thoughts
The best tire is the one that fits your specific trailer, load, and travel habits. There is no one-size-fits-all answer. Use the guide above to match your needs to the key features. When in doubt, always err on the side of a higher load capacity. The peace of mind knowing your tires are more than capable is worth every penny. Regular inspection for cracks, wear, and proper inflation is just as important as the initial purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How often should I replace my horse trailer tires?
A: Follow the “five-year rule” as a general guideline, even if the tread looks good. Trailer tires age from the inside out due to ozone and weather. Cracking in the sidewall or between treads is a clear sign they need replacing, regardless of mileage.
Q: Can I use truck tires on my horse trailer?
A: It’s not recommended. Trailer tires (ST) are specifically designed with stiffer sidewalls to handle the unique stresses of trailering. Passenger (P) or Light Truck (LT) tires have more flexible sidewalls for comfort, which can lead to sway and dangerous handling when used on a trailer.
Q: What is the most important number on a trailer tire?
A: The Load Range (e.g., C, D, E) and the associated maximum load capacity in pounds are critical. This tells you how much weight each tire can safely support. Always choose a tire where the total capacity for all tires exceeds your trailer’s fully loaded weight.
Q: Should I carry a spare tire for my horse trailer?
A: Absolutely, yes. Always carry a properly inflated spare that matches your other tires in size, load range, and condition. A flat on the road is an inconvenience; a flat with no spare is a major emergency, especially with live animals on board.
Investing in the best trailer tires for your horse trailer is a non-negotiable part of responsible ownership. It’s about the safety of your animals, your rig, and everyone on the road with you. We’ve shown you top options from heavy-duty champions to smart budget picks and essential safety tools like the Trailer Aid. Review your trailer’s needs, check those load ratings, and make the choice that lets you hitch up and head out with confidence. Your next adventure awaits—make sure your trailer is ready for it. Ready to find your perfect match? Check the latest prices and secure your tires today.
At CarLegit, we believe information should be clear, factual, and genuinely helpful. That’s why every guide, review, and update on our website is created with care, research, and a strong focus on user experience.