What Happens When Car Accident Claim Exceeds Insurance Limits

Imagine this: You’re driving home from work when another car runs a red light and T-bones your vehicle. You suffer a broken leg, whiplash, and months of physical therapy. Your medical bills pile up, you miss weeks of work, and the emotional toll leaves you anxious behind the wheel. You file a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance—only to learn their policy maxes out at $50,000… but your total damages? Over $150,000.

This scenario isn’t rare. In fact, it’s becoming more common as medical costs rise and many drivers carry minimal coverage. When a car accident claim exceeds insurance limits, the fallout can be financially devastating—even if you weren’t at fault. The good news? You’re not necessarily out of options. Understanding how insurance works, what your rights are, and how to pursue additional compensation can make all the difference between drowning in debt and getting the justice you deserve.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through exactly what happens when a car accident claim exceeds insurance limits, how to protect yourself, and what steps to take if you find yourself in this tough spot. Whether you’re dealing with minor injuries or life-altering trauma, knowing your options empowers you to act wisely—and quickly.

Understanding Insurance Policy Limits

Before diving into what happens when claims surpass coverage, it’s crucial to understand how auto insurance limits work. Every state requires drivers to carry a minimum amount of liability insurance, but those minimums are often dangerously low. For example, California mandates $15,000 per person for bodily injury—but a single ambulance ride can cost more than that.

How Liability Coverage Works

Liability insurance covers damages you cause to others—not yourself. It’s split into two main parts: bodily injury (BI) and property damage (PD). BI pays for the other party’s medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. PD covers vehicle repairs or replacement. These coverages have per-person and per-accident caps. So if your state requires 25/50/25 coverage, that means:

$25,000 max per person for bodily injury
$50,000 max total per accident for all injured parties
$25,000 max for property damage

If your injuries cost $75,000 but the at-fault driver only has 25/50 coverage, their insurer will pay up to $25,000—and stop there.

Why So Many Drivers Are Underinsured

Many people choose the cheapest policy to meet legal requirements, unaware of the risks. A 2023 study by the Insurance Research Council found that nearly 13% of U.S. drivers are uninsured, and even more are underinsured—meaning their coverage is too low to cover serious accidents. Add rising healthcare costs, and it’s easy to see why a “minor” crash can quickly become a financial catastrophe.

The Role of Stacking and Combined Limits

Some states allow “stacking” of policies—for instance, combining coverage from multiple vehicles on the same policy. Others use “combined single limit” (CSL) policies, which pool all liability into one amount (e.g., $100,000 total for any accident). Knowing your state’s rules helps you understand exactly how much protection you—and others—really have.

What Happens After the Insurance Pays Out?

Once the at-fault driver’s insurance reaches its limit, their obligation ends. But your right to seek full compensation doesn’t vanish. Here’s what typically unfolds next.

The Insurance Company Issues a “Release”

Most insurers will ask you to sign a release form once they’ve paid their policy limit. This document states that you accept the payment as full settlement and waive further claims against their insured (the at-fault driver). Never sign this without consulting a lawyer. Once signed, you may lose the right to sue the driver personally—even if your damages far exceed the payout.

You May Still Owe Money

If you’ve already paid medical bills or car repairs out of pocket, and the insurance check doesn’t cover them, you’re left with a shortfall. Worse, if you used your own health insurance or MedPay, those providers may have a right to reimbursement (called subrogation)—meaning they’ll want their money back from any future settlement.

Example: The $80,000 Gap

Let’s say you were rear-ended by a driver with 50/100 coverage. Your medical bills total $90,000, lost wages add $20,000, and pain and suffering are valued at $40,000—totaling $150,000. The insurer pays $50,000 (their per-person BI limit). You’re now $100,000 short. Without additional action, that gap could fall on you.

Your Options Aren’t Over

Just because the insurance money runs out doesn’t mean you’re stuck. You still have legal avenues to pursue the remaining amount—primarily through a personal injury lawsuit or tapping into your own insurance policies.

Can You Sue the At-Fault Driver Personally?

Yes—but with important caveats. When a car accident claim exceeds insurance limits, suing the at-fault driver individually is often the next step. However, winning a judgment and collecting on it are two very different things.

Filing a Personal Injury Lawsuit

If negotiations with the insurer stall or they refuse to pay their full limit, your attorney may recommend filing a lawsuit. This allows a court to determine the true value of your damages and issue a judgment against the driver. The process typically involves:

Filing a complaint in civil court
Discovery (exchanging evidence, depositions)
Mediation or settlement talks
Trial (if no agreement is reached)

A successful verdict could award you the full amount owed—including past and future medical costs, lost earning capacity, and non-economic damages like emotional distress.

Collecting on a Judgment: The Real Challenge

Here’s the hard truth: Many at-fault drivers don’t have significant assets. If they own little property, have modest savings, or earn a low income, collecting a large judgment may be nearly impossible. Courts can authorize tools like:

Wage garnishment (taking a portion of their paycheck)
Bank account levies
Liens on real estate

But if the driver is unemployed, rents their home, or files for bankruptcy, these methods may yield little—or nothing.

When It’s Worth Pursuing

An experienced attorney will evaluate the driver’s financial situation before recommending a lawsuit. If they own a home, have steady income, or possess valuable assets, pursuing a judgment makes sense. But if they’re judgment-proof (no collectible assets), your focus should shift to other sources of recovery—like your own insurance.

Leveraging Your Own Insurance Coverage

One of the most effective ways to bridge the gap when a car accident claim exceeds insurance limits is using your own policy. Many drivers overlook these protections, but they can be lifesavers.

Underinsured Motorist (UIM) Coverage

UIM kicks in when the at-fault driver’s insurance isn’t enough to cover your damages. For example, if you have $100,000 in UIM and the other driver’s policy pays $50,000, your UIM may cover up to $50,000 more—bringing your total to $100,000. Some states require UIM; others offer it as optional add-on. If you don’t have it, consider adding it immediately.

Uninsured Motorist (UM) Coverage

While UM applies when the other driver has no insurance, it often overlaps with UIM in practice. Many policies treat both under the same umbrella. If the at-fault driver is uninsured or underinsured, UM/UIM can step in to cover medical bills, lost wages, and even pain and suffering.

MedPay and PIP: First-Party Benefits

Medical Payments (MedPay) and Personal Injury Protection (PIP) are no-fault coverages that pay your medical expenses regardless of who caused the crash. MedPay is usually small ($5,000–$10,000), but PIP can be substantial—covering up to $250,000 in some states. These benefits can be used immediately, reducing out-of-pocket costs while you negotiate with the at-fault party’s insurer.

Collision and Comprehensive Coverage

These cover your vehicle repairs, not injuries. If your car is totaled and the at-fault driver’s PD limit is too low, your collision coverage can cover the difference (minus your deductible). Always check your policy details—some insurers allow you to “stack” collision with UIM for total loss scenarios.

Example: Using UIM to Close the Gap

Back to our earlier example: $150,000 in damages, $50,000 from the other driver’s insurance. If you have $100,000 in UIM, your insurer may pay the remaining $100,000—fully covering your claim. No lawsuit needed. This is why carrying higher UIM limits is one of the smartest moves you can make.

Negotiating Settlements and Avoiding Pitfalls

When a car accident claim exceeds insurance limits, settlement talks become even more critical. Insurers know you’re vulnerable and may pressure you to accept less than you deserve.

Don’t Rush to Settle

It’s tempting to take the first offer—especially if you’re facing mounting bills. But once you settle, you typically can’t reopen the claim, even if your injuries worsen. Wait until you’ve reached maximum medical improvement (MMI)—the point where your condition has stabilized—before agreeing to anything.

Beware of Lowball Offers

Insurance adjusters are trained to minimize payouts. They may argue your injuries aren’t serious, downplay pain and suffering, or claim you were partially at fault. Don’t fall for it. Keep detailed records: doctor visits, prescriptions, therapy notes, photos of injuries, and receipts for everything related to the accident.

The Power of a Demand Letter

Your attorney can send a formal demand letter outlining all damages, supported by evidence. This shows the insurer you’re serious and prepared to litigate. Often, this prompts a higher offer—sometimes even the full policy limit.

Consider Structured Settlements

If you win a large judgment but worry about the at-fault driver’s ability to pay, a structured settlement spreads payments over time. This can provide steady income for ongoing medical needs or lost wages.

Tax Implications

Generally, compensation for physical injuries is tax-free. But portions tied to lost wages or punitive damages may be taxable. Consult a tax professional to understand your obligations.

How to Protect Yourself in the Future

No one plans to be in a serious accident—but you can reduce your risk of financial ruin if it happens.

Review and Upgrade Your Policy Annually

Don’t just auto-renew. Each year, reassess your coverage. Ask: “If I were seriously injured by an underinsured driver, could I recover fully?” Aim for UIM limits that match or exceed your liability coverage.

Consider an Umbrella Policy

An umbrella policy provides extra liability protection beyond your auto and home insurance—typically $1 million or more. While it protects you if you cause an accident, it also signals to insurers that you value comprehensive coverage, which can influence how they handle your claims.

Document Everything—Always

From the moment of impact, start a file. Save police reports, witness contacts, medical records, and even text messages about the crash. The more evidence you have, the stronger your position when negotiating or litigating.

Know Your State’s Laws

Laws vary widely. In some states, you can sue for pain and suffering immediately; in others, you must meet a “serious injury” threshold. Some allow you to recover from your own insurer even if the other driver is uncooperative. Understanding local rules helps you act faster and smarter.

Build a Relationship with a Trusted Attorney

You don’t need to hire a lawyer for every fender bender—but having one on speed dial for serious crashes is wise. Many personal injury attorneys work on contingency (no win, no fee), so there’s little risk in consulting early.

Conclusion

When a car accident claim exceeds insurance limits, the financial stakes skyrocket. The at-fault driver’s insurer won’t pay more than their policy allows—but that doesn’t mean you’re out of luck. By understanding your rights, leveraging your own coverage (especially UIM), and working with a skilled attorney, you can pursue the full compensation you deserve.

Remember: Insurance is meant to protect you, not just comply with the law. Don’t let low limits leave you vulnerable. Review your policy today, consider higher coverage, and know that even when the other driver’s insurance falls short, you still have options. Stay informed, stay prepared, and drive with confidence—knowing you’re protected no matter what the road throws your way.

FAQs

Can I still get paid if the at-fault driver has no assets?

It’s difficult but not impossible. If the driver has no collectible assets, a judgment may be unenforceable. However, your own underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage can often fill the gap—so having robust personal insurance is key.

Will my insurance rates go up if I use my UIM coverage?

Generally, no—especially if you weren’t at fault. Using UIM is considered a “no-fault” claim in most states, so it shouldn’t impact your premiums. Always confirm with your insurer.

How long do I have to file a lawsuit after an accident?

This depends on your state’s statute of limitations, typically ranging from 1 to 6 years. Missing the deadline bars you from suing, so act quickly and consult a lawyer as soon as possible.

What if I was partially at fault?

In most states, you can still recover damages even if you’re partly responsible—but your award will be reduced by your percentage of fault. For example, if you’re 20% at fault, you’ll receive 80% of the total damages.

Can the insurance company refuse to pay their full limit?

Rarely—if liability is clear and damages exceed the limit, they’re obligated to pay up to the policy cap. However, they may dispute fault or the severity of injuries, so strong documentation is essential.

Should I talk to the at-fault driver’s insurance company?

Be cautious. While you may need to provide basic information, avoid giving recorded statements or admitting fault. Let your attorney handle communications to protect your rights.

This is a comprehensive guide about What Happens When Car Accident Claim Exceeds Insurance Limits.

Key Takeaways

Understanding What Happens When Car Accident Claim Exceeds Insurance Limits: Provides essential knowledge

Frequently Asked Questions

What is What Happens When Car Accident Claim Exceeds Insurance Limits?

What Happens When Car Accident Claim Exceeds Insurance Limits is an important topic with many practical applications.

Carlegit

At CarLegit, we believe information should be clear, factual, and genuinely helpful. That’s why every guide, review, and update on our website is created with care, research, and a strong focus on user experience.

Key Takeaways